Although Toronto is sitting dead last in the NHL, this may be one of the most exciting times to be a Leafs fan. Yes, that may have been the first time anyone has said that- but hear me out. For the first time in many years, the team actually seems to have a bright future, and the light at the end of the tunnel may be closer than it seems. Between the trade deadline, June's NHL draft, and the rest of the off-season, come October Toronto may ice one of the most promising lineups they've had since the early 2000's. This article will provide breakdown of what Lou Lamoriello and the rest of Toronto's management did right and wrong at this year's deadline.
Despite a coupe miscues, Toronto actually had a fairly good trading spree at the deadline. The Leafs have set themselves up with two first round picks and three second round picks in this year's draft, and have set themselves up for future success. Although I'm still unbelievably salty about the Reimer deal and not getting rid of Parenteau, for the first time in a very long time, I'm optimistic about the coming years. Good work, Lou, I
salute you.
The Good
Roman Polak and Nick Spaling- In simple terms, the Leafs got a lot, for Roman Polak and Nick Spaling. Two second-round picks for a fourth or fifth defenceman and a player with 7 points in 35 games is, well, not the greatest deal Doug Wilson has ever made. But hey, Toronto will take it, plus getting Raffi Torres? Gamechanger. Kidding aside, this deal was perfect for Toronto.
The (Very) Bad
I wasn't completely opposed to seeing Reimer dealt at the deadline, but this trade was just brutal. It didn't make sense to give him the reported 6 year, $6M contract that he was asking for, but James Reimer was a starting goalie, and the return Toronto got for him was insulting. Two players that go into free agency this season, and a fourth round pick in 2018? I get that the Leafs want to get a better look at Sparks, but they just gave away an NHL starter heading into the prime of his career for nothing at all.
Why are they still here?
Roman Polak and Nick Spaling- In simple terms, the Leafs got a lot, for Roman Polak and Nick Spaling. Two second-round picks for a fourth or fifth defenceman and a player with 7 points in 35 games is, well, not the greatest deal Doug Wilson has ever made. But hey, Toronto will take it, plus getting Raffi Torres? Gamechanger. Kidding aside, this deal was perfect for Toronto.
Daniel Winnik- Even though Winnik had a year left on his contract, a second-round pick and Connor Carrick was worth losing him a year early. Laich was likely only part of the deal to keep the Capitals above water in terms of cap space, but like Michalek, it's doubtful Laich will spend too much time around the ACC past this season.
Shawn Matthias- Shawn Matthias was a forgotten player whose departure was overshadowed by the Roman Polak deal. Nonetheless, Matthias, a soon-to-be UFA, brought back a fourth-r
ound pick and prospect Colin Smith from Colorado. This is a very low-impact deal for both teams, as Smith will be sent to the Marlies, and the pick isn't substantial. Altogether not a bad trade for either team.
Shawn Matthias- Shawn Matthias was a forgotten player whose departure was overshadowed by the Roman Polak deal. Nonetheless, Matthias, a soon-to-be UFA, brought back a fourth-r
ound pick and prospect Colin Smith from Colorado. This is a very low-impact deal for both teams, as Smith will be sent to the Marlies, and the pick isn't substantial. Altogether not a bad trade for either team.
The (Very) Bad
I wasn't completely opposed to seeing Reimer dealt at the deadline, but this trade was just brutal. It didn't make sense to give him the reported 6 year, $6M contract that he was asking for, but James Reimer was a starting goalie, and the return Toronto got for him was insulting. Two players that go into free agency this season, and a fourth round pick in 2018? I get that the Leafs want to get a better look at Sparks, but they just gave away an NHL starter heading into the prime of his career for nothing at all.Why are they still here?
Between P-A Parenteau, Michael Grabner, Brad Boyes and others, the Leafs certainly loaded themselves up with their share of deadline trade pieces this summer, but decided not to pull the trigger on any of them.
P-A Parenteau- The 32 year-old forward was Toronto's biggest bait for the deadline. Though there's been talk of Parenteau re-signing, he's only getting older, and Toronto was wrong to not take advantage of what he could have brought back. Parenteau should have had no trouble going for at least a prospect and a second-round pick, or a deal similar to how Antoine Vermette was dealt last deadline. If Parenteau isn't back in a Leafs jersey next year, Toronto made a horrible mistake.
Brad Boyes- Boyes will almost certainly head to free agency and not re-sign, and he could have brought back either a pick or an average prospect. Toronto lost out.
Michael Grabner- There was a lot more expected of Grabner when Toronto gave up five prospects for him. Skip to now, Grabner has been largely useless, scoring only 11 points in a Leafs' uniform, while having the worst season of his career. Nonetheless, Grabner could have still brought back a mid/late round pick back or a B level prospect. His trade would have also freed up $3M more salary cap space. Grabner is better than how he's been playing, but Grabner shouldn't be taking a spot on the wing away from a prospect next season.
Michael Grabner- There was a lot more expected of Grabner when Toronto gave up five prospects for him. Skip to now, Grabner has been largely useless, scoring only 11 points in a Leafs' uniform, while having the worst season of his career. Nonetheless, Grabner could have still brought back a mid/late round pick back or a B level prospect. His trade would have also freed up $3M more salary cap space. Grabner is better than how he's been playing, but Grabner shouldn't be taking a spot on the wing away from a prospect next season.
Trading these three forwards would have cleared up an extra $5.2M in cap space for Toronto. Especially after acquiring Laich, Toronto really needed at least one of these forwards to have room for a big off-season signing (*cough* Stamkos *cough*).
Despite a coupe miscues, Toronto actually had a fairly good trading spree at the deadline. The Leafs have set themselves up with two first round picks and three second round picks in this year's draft, and have set themselves up for future success. Although I'm still unbelievably salty about the Reimer deal and not getting rid of Parenteau, for the first time in a very long time, I'm optimistic about the coming years. Good work, Lou, Isalute you.
















